GR9277 #64



Alternate Solutions 
There are no Alternate Solutions for this problem. Be the first to post one! 

Comments 
NoPhysicist3 20170323 12:31:21  The words \"certain region\" are VERY confusing. However, when choosing between B and E, one should keep in mind that it is unlikely for ETS to consider a correct answer containing ultimate statements. Therefore B is the only correct.   Naismith 20111010 04:30:08  What do they mean by "in a certain region" ? In my opinion, it is always possible to find a region small enough so that it doesn't contain any charges, therefore charge density. The charge then will be outside the region...
h.fei10 20121104 07:42:12 
That's not possible. The electric field pevades this certain region, so does the charge.

calcuttj 20140903 17:57:04 
Think about the field inside a cylinder of constant charge density.
The cylinder has radius R, constrain r < R such that
E*r^2d = r^3d
(d is the length of our Gaussian cylinder)
E = r
The region could be the z axis inside the cylinder
Not necessarily the only charge distribution to create E =kz, and this definitely doesn't prove there is ALWAYS a distribution to create a field like this, but it definitely disproves that the field is impossible
Now think about this. If there wasn't a charge density in the region. shouldn't the field be decreasing (i.e. E=k/z)?

calcuttj 20140910 16:36:07 
I made a mistake in my last comment, ignore it.

  r10101 20071027 16:32:37  Why does a small region of vacuum near the surface of an infinite charged plate (with constant = E normal to the surface) not satisfy this question, making answer (E) correct?
panos85 20071031 05:12:32 
It says , not . The electric field near the surface of a conductor is constant, while the field in this problem is not.

tonyhong 20081025 01:54:24 
this is a trap...

  sharpstones 20061201 10:25:11  how could you possibly construct a charge density that would make such an E field?
mhas035 20070404 23:58:56 
Remember that it says that the field is only in a certain region. We just need the region to be small with a relatively large charged plane of constant charge density.

evanb 20080624 11:56:52 
How about a uniformdensity infiniteplane slab. So, it would be thick and the region of interest would be from the middle of the slab to the edge of the slab.

 




The Sidebar Chatbox...
Scroll to see it, or resize your browser to ignore it... 

