GREPhysics.NET: GR9277 #53

GREPhysics.NET

GR9277 #53

Problem

GREPhysics.NET Official Solution

Alternate Solutions

\prob{53}
A particle of mass m is confined to an infinitely deep square-well potential:
$<br /> V(x)&=&\infty,\;\;x\leq0,x\geq a \\<br /> V(x)&=&0,\;\;0\lt x \lt a<br />$

The normalized eigenfunctions, labeled by the quantum number n, are $\psi_n=\sqrt{\frac{2}{a}}\sin \frac{n\pi x}{a}$

A measurement of energy E will always satisfy which of the following relationships?

$E\leq\frac{\pi^2\hbar^2}{8ma^2}$
$E\leq\frac{\pi^2\hbar^2}{2ma^2}$
$E=\frac{\pi^2\hbar^2}{8ma^2}$
$E=\frac{n^2\pi^2\hbar^2}{8ma^2}$
$E=\frac{\pi^2\hbar^2}{2ma^2}$

Quantum Mechanics $\Rightarrow$ }Energy

If one forgets the energy of an infinite well, one can quickly derive it from the time-independent Schrodinger's Equation $-\frac{\hbar}{2m}\psi^{''}+V\psi = E\psi$ . However, since $V=0$ inside, one has $-\frac{\hbar}{2m}\psi^{''} = E\psi$ .

Plug in the ground-state wave function $\psi = A \sin(kx)$ , where $k=n\pi/a$ . Chunk out the second derivative to get $E=\frac{k^2 \hbar^2}{2m}$ . Plug in k to get $E=\frac{\hbar^2 n^2 \pi^2}{2ma^2}$ .

Note that $k=n\pi/a$ can be deduced from boundary conditions, i.e., the wave function vanishes at both ends ( $\psi(0)=0$ and $\psi(a)=0$ ). The second boundary condition forces the n's to be integers. Since one can't have a trivial wave function, $|n| \geq 1$ , and thus $n^2 \geq 1$ . One finds that $E \geq \frac{\pi^2 \hbar^2}{2m a^2}$ , since $n=1,2,3...$ , as in choice (E).

See below for user comments and alternate solutions!

Alternate Solutions

panos85
2007-10-30 11:31:21

The energy depends on n so it cannot be a constant. This eliminates C, D, E. Furthermore it cannot be bounded from above as it increases with n. (You can easily remember that.) So A is out. Choice B remains.

Reply to this comment

Alternate Solution - Unverified

Comments

francesco
2017-09-14 20:26:58

if you look at the eigenfunctions (in particular, at the argument of the sine) you can deduce that $k = \\frac{n\\pi}{a}$ , plug it in $E = \\frac{\\hbar^2 k^2}{2m}$ and find choice B

Reply to this comment

NEC

syreen
2013-09-18 13:47:54

The Schrodinger EQ should have hbar^2, not just hbar.

Also, as others have noted, the typed question has a typo. B. should have E>=, NOT E<=

Reply to this comment

NEC

Kabuto Yakushi
2010-09-04 08:58:08

As long as you remember (which it is probably a good idea to memorize for this test) the energy in a potential well to be

E = $\frac{\pi^2\hbar^2}{2ma^2}$

with a note that using $\hbar^2$ results in a two not an eight on the bottom, choice (B) is obvious. (C),(D), and (E) are to precise to satisfy the "always" criteria.

Reply to this comment

NEC

Fizzics
2009-10-30 11:44:19

Well I tried to post that last thing as a typo.

Reply to this comment

Typo Alert!

Fizzics
2009-10-30 11:43:33

The Answer should be "B" not "E". And the answer shown in the problem as "B" is wrong. Should be E is GREATER THAN or EQUAL TO.

Typos.

Reply to this comment

NEC

jw111
2008-11-04 11:45:30

Since $E=\frac{p^2}{2m}$
and $p=H*k$ where H = h bar

so $E=\frac{H^2k^2}{2m}$

with the solution given by question,
$k=\frac{n\pi}{a}$

thus
$E=\frac{n^2\pi^2H^2}{2ma^2}$

Reply to this comment

NEC

Monk
2008-10-13 21:46:07

(hbar)^2 is missing in the original presentation of the TISE, it just shows (hbar)...though most of you should know that anyhow :P

Reply to this comment

NEC

adenos
2007-11-02 12:49:53

B should read E >= ....

evanb
2008-06-23 19:07:46

yes.

evanb
2008-06-23 19:11:02

Dammit, the preview de-TYPO-ified my entry.

Yes, (B) should be >= and not <=

and it should be the answer, not (E)

Reply to this comment

NEC

panos85
2007-10-30 11:31:21

The energy depends on n so it cannot be a constant. This eliminates C, D, E. Furthermore it cannot be bounded from above as it increases with n. (You can easily remember that.) So A is out. Choice B remains.

hoyas08
2008-06-16 19:52:47

Unfortunately, choice D has an $n^2$ term in it, so you can't eliminate it by reasoning that the energy must depend on n. However, if you can remember that the energy of a particle in free space (V=0) is E= $\frac{\vec{p}^2}{2m}$ , then the 8 in the denominator of D does not make sense.

hoyas08
2008-06-16 19:55:05

Unfortunately, choice D has an $n^2$ term in it, so you can't eliminate it by reasoning that the energy must depend on $n$ . However, if you can remember that the energy of a particle in free space (V=0) is E= $\frac{\vec{p}^2}{2m}$ , then the 8 in the denominator of D doesn't make sense, eliminating that answer.

Imperate
2008-10-16 10:18:38

This is not true for D, D has E=n^2... which is the correct form.rnrnOne can throw away A becayse there is no upper bound to energy.rnOne can throw away C and E because they [b] are [/b] constants, which is unacceptable for the energy.rnrnThis leaves B and D, and D can only be eliminated by working out the correct coeff, as others have posted.rnrnI think this question is a bit harsh though because from elementary QM infinite square wells always have n^2 dependence so you see D whilst doing a high speed test like the GRE then you are going to pick D, well I did anyway....rnrnI

ramparts
2009-08-06 19:24:55

How does that eliminate D? D is dependent on n.

ramparts
2009-08-06 19:24:55

How does that eliminate D? D is dependent on n.

Reply to this comment

Alternate Solution - Unverified

antithesis
2007-10-05 18:17:17

Aside from typos mentioned, the question itself has a typo, B should have equal or greater than

Reply to this comment

NEC

Mexicana
2007-10-04 17:46:32

It is much easier to derive this by getting the zero point energy via Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle $\delta x \delta p = h/2\pi$ and then square this expression. Now just substitute for $\delta x= a$ where $a$ is the width of the square well and then the usual expression for momentum $(\delta p)^2 = 2m E$ .

Tommy Koulax
2007-10-29 09:53:59

doesn't that lead to E= $\frac{(h bar)^2}{2*m*a^2}$ which is not an option provided?

Reply to this comment

NEC

georgi
2007-08-26 20:20:13

as everyone is posting the answer should be choice b, not e as written

Reply to this comment

NEC

welshmj
2007-07-12 15:51:47

Choice B is the correct answer not E, but choice B on this page has a typo. It should be greater than or equal to, not less than or equal to.

Reply to this comment

NEC

JB
2005-12-07 02:32:15

Isn't your answer choice (B)

jcain6
2005-12-08 19:20:24

It should be choice (B) because the question requires E to ALWAYS satisfy the relationship. Choice (E) only works when the potential is 0 between o and a.

Andresito
2006-03-27 15:43:35

I also think it is (B).

sirius
2008-06-25 13:05:18

the potential is 0 from 0 to a. it says so in the problem. this is a particle in an infinite square well, and answer (E) is the only answer that makes sense.

sirius
2008-06-25 13:09:59

nevermind, i misread which had the >=, i agree it is (B)

Reply to this comment

Typo Alert!

jcain6
2005-11-22 19:06:10

Your missing a (hbar)^2 in your numerator.

yosun
2005-11-23 02:00:51

jcain6: thanks for the typo-alert; it's been corrected.

Reply to this comment

Fixed Typos!

Post A Comment!

You are replying to:

Aside from typos mentioned, the question itself has a typo, B should have equal or greater than

Bare Basic LaTeX Rosetta Stone
LaTeX syntax supported through dollar sign wrappers $, ex., $\alpha^2_0$ produces $\alpha^2_0$ .
type this...	to get...
$\int_0^\infty$	$\int_0^\infty$
$\partial$	$\partial$
$\Rightarrow$	$\Rightarrow$
$\ddot{x},\dot{x}$	$\ddot{x},\dot{x}$
$\sqrt{z}$	$\sqrt{z}$
$\langle my \rangle$	$\langle my \rangle$
$\left( abacadabra \right)_{me}$	$\left( abacadabra \right)_{me}$
$\vec{E}$	$\vec{E}$
$\frac{a}{b}$	$\frac{a}{b}$

The Sidebar Chatbox...
Scroll to see it, or resize your browser to ignore it...

All-Solutions List | Latest Comments | Unanswered Questions (Cries for Help!) |::| About

© 2005-2007 by Yosun Chang, All rights reserved.

This site is not affiliated with ETS, nor is it officially endorsed (yet) by ETS. This site is the work of an individual named Yosun Chang. The solutions, sans user comments and ETS questions, are © 2005 by Yosun Chang except where noted. All rights reserved. / The comments appending particular solutions are due to the respective users. / Educational Testing Service, ETS, the ETS logo, Graduate Record Examinations, and GRE are registered trademarks of Educational Testing Service. The examination questions are © 1997 and © 2001 by ETS.