GREPhysics.NET: GR9277 #44

GR9277 #44

Problem

GREPhysics.NET Official Solution

\prob{44}
A particle of mass m on the Earth's surface is confined to move on the parabolic curve $y=ax^2$ , where y is up. Which of the following is a Lagrangian for the particle?

$L=\frac{1}{2}m\ddot{y}^2\left(1+\frac{1}{4ay}\right)-mgy$
$L=\frac{1}{2}m\dot{y}^2\left(1-\frac{1}{4ay}\right)-mgy$
$L=\frac{1}{2}m\dot{x}^2\left(1+\frac{1}{4ax}\right)-mgx$
$L=\frac{1}{2}m\dot{x}^2\left(1+4a^2x^2\right)+mgx$
$L=\frac{1}{2}m\dot{x}^2+\frac{1}{2}m\dot{y}^2+mgy$

Mechanics $\Rightarrow$ }Lagrangians

The kinetic energy, in general, is given by $T=\frac{1}{2}m(\dot{x}^2+\dot{y}^2)$ . The potential energy is just $V=mgy$ . The Lagrangian is given by $L=T-V=\frac{1}{2}m(\dot{x}^2+\dot{y}^2)-mgy$ .

Now, given the constraint $y=ax^2$ , one can differentiate it and plug it into the Lagrangian above to reexpress the Lagrangian in terms of just y, for example.

Differentiating, one has $\frac{d}{dt}(y=ax^2) \Rightarrow \dot{y}=a2x\dot{x} \Rightarrow \dot{x}=\dot{y}/(2ax)$ . Square that to get $\dot{x}^2=\frac{\dot{y}^2}{4a^2x^2}=\frac{\dot{y}^2}{4ay}$ , where one replaces the $x^2$ through the given relation $y=ax^2$ .

Plug that back into the Lagrangian above to get exactly choice (A).

Alternate Solutions

rrfan
2011-11-06 12:45:34

The Lagrangian is $L=T-V$ , where $T=\frac{1}{2}(\dot{x}^2+\dot{y}^2)$ and $V=-mgy$ . Only choices (A) and (B) contain $-mgy$ . Of these two, only (A) is possible because $T$ must be greater than or equal to $\frac{1}{2}\dot{y}^2$ .

Reply to this comment

Comments

rrfan
2011-11-06 12:45:34

RusFortunat
2015-10-22 16:32:57

$V=mgy$

Reply to this comment

Quark
2011-10-26 15:17:39

This is probably a silly question but, why would one be wrong in choosing choice (E)? I actually picked the right answer (A) on the test but glancing over it again, (E) is also correct in the most general form. Is it not explicit enough? lol

rrfan
2011-11-06 13:14:00

the +mgy is wrong.

livieratos
2011-11-08 14:41:41

also if i remember correctly, since the two coordinates of each other the Lagrangian has to be dependent only on one of them and on its time derivative, not both...
but i could be wrong. guess i should read lagrange and hamilton again :P

Reply to this comment

$null
2009-10-28 16:39:52

Reposted to $typo$ section...(with sexy LaTeX)

There is a typo in Answer A, it should be $\dot{y}^2$ , not $\ddot{y}^2$

Reply to this comment

tan
2009-10-14 23:52:17

There is a typo in Answer A, it should be y dot, not y double dot.

Reply to this comment

mdornfe1
2008-11-06 16:58:28

This can be done by noticing that potential energy has to be -mgy. A and B are only answers with this property. Second the kinetic energy must always be positive 1-(4ay)^-1 is not always positive. So choice A is the answer.

his dudeness
2010-09-04 13:42:09

well done, brah

TeamGandalf
2011-04-01 18:12:40

The Lagrangian is equal to T-V. Why doesn't the negative from the Potential cancel the negative in the equation?

Why isn't it L = T - (-mgy)= T + mgy?

Quark
2011-10-26 15:20:37

@TeamGandalf

The lagrangian is L = T - U. You can't have a negative potential energy... U=mgy not (-mgy).

Reply to this comment

Poop Loops
2008-10-12 00:45:40

So what happens when y = 0, as it inevitably will when the particle comes back down?

segfault
2009-09-04 12:14:26

(I realize I'm replying to a 1 year old post--this is for the general public). When y->0, the $1+\frac{1}{4ay}$ term will blow up but $\dot{y}=2ax\dot{x}$ will be zero, so L won't blow up. Perhaps if L was written in terms of $x$ it would have a nicer form...

Reply to this comment

etano
2007-06-16 14:12:37

There is a typo in Answer A, it should be y dot, not y double dot.

Reply to this comment

Post A Comment!

Bare Basic LaTeX Rosetta Stone
LaTeX syntax supported through dollar sign wrappers $, ex., $\alpha^2_0$ produces $\alpha^2_0$ .
type this...	to get...
$\int_0^\infty$	$\int_0^\infty$
$\partial$	$\partial$
$\Rightarrow$	$\Rightarrow$
$\ddot{x},\dot{x}$	$\ddot{x},\dot{x}$
$\sqrt{z}$	$\sqrt{z}$
$\langle my \rangle$	$\langle my \rangle$
$\left( abacadabra \right)_{me}$	$\left( abacadabra \right)_{me}$
$\vec{E}$	$\vec{E}$
$\frac{a}{b}$	$\frac{a}{b}$

The Sidebar Chatbox...
Scroll to see it, or resize your browser to ignore it...

All-Solutions List | Latest Comments | Unanswered Questions (Cries for Help!) |::| About

This site is not affiliated with ETS, nor is it officially endorsed (yet) by ETS. This site is the work of an individual named Yosun Chang. The solutions, sans user comments and ETS questions, are © 2005 by Yosun Chang except where noted. All rights reserved. / The comments appending particular solutions are due to the respective users. / Educational Testing Service, ETS, the ETS logo, Graduate Record Examinations, and GRE are registered trademarks of Educational Testing Service. The examination questions are © 1997 and © 2001 by ETS.

Bare Basic LaTeX Rosetta Stone